The challenges of managing superstars

Bruce Tulgan

You want a whole team of superstars. In a free market, you get what you can negotiate. As the manager, you do have the discretion and resources to differentiate those superstars the way they deserve to be recognized and rewarded. If every condition of employment — not just pay, but schedule, duration of employment, location, assignments, and so on — is on the table, your negotiating position as a manager is stronger, not weaker.

Invest in your Superstars in every way you possibly can. That means your time and every training, development, and stretch-assignment opportunities you can muster, not to mention the best resources of every sort. Pay the superstars what they are worth, especially when they go the extra mile, even if it is more than their counterparts who produce less. Be flexible about where or when those superstars work, in most cases, as long as they get the job done very well and ahead of schedule.

  • Whatever you are doing to be flexible and generous to retain your good employees, you need to be much more flexible and generous to keep your great employees engaged, motivated, and committed. When favoring superstars, consider:
  • Whatever one-on-one time you give to your good employees, spend more time with your superstars and prepare for that time like you are preparing for a meeting with your boss’s boss. Make sure your one-on-ones with superstars are a great use of everybody’s time.
  • However your good employees are assigned to work with vendors, customers, coworkers, subordinates, and managers, give your great employees first choice in relationship opportunities at work
  • However tasks and responsibilities are assigned to good employees, give your great employees first choice. Give the great ones first choice on any special projects or choice assignments.
  • Whatever training opportunities are being made available to good employees, offer the best training resources to the best people first.
  • Whatever you are you paying your good employees, pay your great ones more. Consider giving them more in base pay and benefits. Definitely give them more bonus money contingent on clear performance benchmarks tied directly to concrete actions they can control.
  • Whatever kind of scheduling flexibility are you providing for your good employees, give your great ones the best schedules, and give them more control over when they work.
  • However good employees are assigned to work locations or work spaces and travel, give the best people the first choice of location, work space, and travel.

The more you are able to help the superstars customize their roles, work conditions, and ability to get paid, the longer you will keep them engaged, motivated, and committed. You can be sure that the superstar is thrilled at the prospect of building the next stage of her career. The only question is will the superstar be thrilled to do that on this team here reporting to you. Do you have what it takes to continue leading this superstar?

ABOUT THE AUTHORBruce Tulgan is an adviser to business leaders all over the world and a sought-after keynote speaker and seminar leader. He is the founder and CEO of RainmakerThinking, Inc., a management research and training firm, as well as RainmakerThinking.Training, an online training company. Bruce is the best-selling author of numerous books including Not Everyone Gets a Trophy (Revised & Updated, 2016), Bridging the Soft Skills Gap (2015), The 27 Challenges Managers Face (2014), , and It’s Okay to be the Boss (2007). He has written for the New York Times, the Harvard Business Review, HR Magazine, Training Magazine, and the Huffington Post. Bruce can be reached by e-mail at brucet@rainmakerthinking.com, you can follow him on Twitter @BruceTulgan, or visit his website www.rainmakerthinking.com.


10 Tips to Writing Job Ads in a Candidate Tight Ma...

Drake Editorial

In a candidate tight market, attracting talent can seem like an impossible task, but it doesn't have to be. One tool to help you in your hiring process is how you write your job ads. Here are 10 tips to help you write effective job ads in a candidate tight market.

Read more


What is a micro-manager and why is it bad for busi...

Drake International

We’ve all heard the term, or even experienced a little dose of micro-management, you may have even been guilty of it yourself! It is easy to point the finger at a perceived micro-manager and label them as an aggressive, power-hungry monster. However, the psychology behind this behaviour is much more complex and can put even us ordinary folk at risk of micro-managing behaviour.

Read more


Drake WorkWise Mindfulness Webinar

Drake Editorial Team

Are you feeling stressed at home or at work due to COVID-19? Drake WorkWise have put on a valuable webinar on mindfulness. Click through to watch the webinar.

Read more


Do You Need More Emotional Agility?

Michelle McQuaid

How do you deal with your difficult emotions? Do you try to wish them away, bottle them up or stew over them? Do you get worried that you’re worried, unhappy that you’re unhappy or stressed that you’re stressed? Is there a better way to deal with these emotions?

Read more


How to Navigate your Business through Turbulent ti...

Drake Editorial

COVID has caused unprecedented challenges for big and small businesses. Here are some tips for leading your team and your business through tough and turbulent times.


Read more


3 Ways to Turn Self-Criticism Into Self-Compassion...

Michelle McQuaid

Do you ever hear a little voice chattering away in your head that fills you with self-doubt? Perhaps you’ve heard it saying “You’re not good enough,” “You’re so lazy,” or even “You’re such an idiot.” It’s the voice of self-criticism that says things to you that you would never dare say to anyone else.

Read more