Engagement is an inside job

Jim Clemmer

When faced with major organizational problems, managers often hire consultants to help provide a solution. The consultant will usually interview people, run focus groups, and gather input from a variety of sources. Many good ideas are sifted through and the most relevant one presented to management along with the consultant's recommended action plan.

Frequently the ideas that most excite managers are ones that have existed inside the organization for years. Yet managers are often hearing them for the first time. Or they are finally paying attention because the ideas are coming from outside experts. This points to a major failure of leadership within the organization. In such cases, managers will often have tried to solicit ideas using various formalized approaches, such as suggestion boxes. These are rarely effective. A disgruntled staff member once put a sign on a suggestion box that summed up the consensus view of this approach: "Please don't put any more ideas in here. The handle is broken and it won't flush." Instead, the organization needs to focus on the leadership values of partnership, participation, and involvement. Without these values there is no system that can foster the communication necessary to keep ideas flowing.

The organization “Success Profiles” studied 150 companies to understand the impact of "a business excelling in Feedback and Engagement where employees work each day in an environment where their feedback is elicited, valued, and acted upon." They found the companies that best met this description experienced revenue growth many times higher than those companies with low levels of feedback and engagement. They also studied organizational communication and employee access to information, and discovered that "companies demonstrating poor performance in this business practice had nearly twice the employee turnover as those companies achieving only average performance."

The evidence clearly shows that building partnerships through involvement and participation is the strong leadership factor that leads to high performance:

  • "Companies that adopt employee involvement measures such as work teams and employee participation in decision making, are likely to find significant rewards on their bottom line," says a report produced by the University of Southern California's Marshall School of Business. They found that the average return on sales was 8.3 percent among low-involvement companies versus 10.4 percent among high-involvement firms. Stock price appreciation was 21 percent versus 44 percent.
  • A study of franchise systems found that one of the greatest differentiators among the most successful franchisees was "a belief that employees deserve trust, enjoy responsibility and offer meaningful contributions to the business." One of the study's researchers concluded, "The managers who involve their employees were much more successful in the performance of their franchise than those who distrust employees and exclude them from decisions."
  • A study by Success Profiles analyzed the relationship between effectively giving people authority to make decisions and compounded revenue growth. They found that companies who scored "Poor" in this key leadership practice had a 2.3 percent compound growth rate. Those companies that scored "Very Good" on giving authority to make decisions had an 11.1 percent rate of compound growth!
  • In an article entitled "Happy Companies Make Happy Investments," Fortune reports that "You can make a killing by making nice." Companies on the annual 100 Best Companies to Work For lists had an average return on investment of 18.2 percent, versus the S & P 500 average of 5.7 percent during that same time period. "So managers, be kind and honest. Your employees and shareholders will thank you."
  • A study by J. Howard & Associates in a large insurance company found that the 20 percent of managers that were seen as least inclusive ran the least profitable units. This contrasts with the 20 percent of managers considered to be the most inclusive who had units with 60 percent higher profitability. They also had lower turnover rates and higher customer satisfaction ratings.

The man who gets the most satisfactory results is not always the man with the most brilliant single mind, but rather the man who can best coordinate the brains and talents of his associates." — Sir William Alton Jones, 18th century British philologist and jurist


Reprinted with the permission of Jim Clemmer whose practical leadership & personal growth books, workshops, and team retreats have helped hundreds of thousands of people worldwide improve personal, team, and organizational performance. An international best-selling author, his latest book is Growing@the Speed of Change. Visit JimClemmer.com for more information on his books, monthly newsletter, and leadership blog.


The 10 golden rules of HR analytics

Patrick Coolen

Applying statistical methods, like regression analyses, on data sets that combine HR and business data. The latter allows you to really determine the impact of HR elements...

Read More


How to build highly effective teams

Carter McNamara

Too often, teams are formed merely by gathering some people together and then hoping that those people somehow find a way to work together successfully. Teams are most effective when carefully designed.

Read More


How to help others resolve conflict

Ken Warren

Managers often wonder what they would do with the extra time if they didn’t have to deal with difficulties between team members...

Read More


How to reduce staff turnover by spotting the 10 si...

Drake Editorial

It's a bitter pill to swallow, but regardless of how good your organisation is, employees are always going to leave. The question is, how can you minimise the number of resignations?

Read more


Re-engaging the disengaged team member

Ken Warren

Is there someone at your work who has mentally quit, but physically stayed? Are they lacking motivation, not really contributing to their team or organisation overall? 

Read more


That was horrible! what makes feedback work...or n...

David Swink

We are all on learning journeys. At work, we are learning new professional and technical skills. In our communities, we are learning to make a difference, be a good friend, neighbor, or weekend athlete.

Read More